Constructively Criticize the Previous Poster

[Yelnoc]

I don't think we have done this one yet.  Say one thing the previous poster needs to improve.  Remember, constructive criticism.

[For Oklahoma]

You need a lower social score and a higher econ score

[Governor Scott]

You need to not be an Anarchist.

[Zach Vega]

You should have your siggy take up less pixels.

[Senator Snowstalker]

You should stop unironically liking the Chipmunks.

[TJ in Wisco]

You should stop talking about ponies ironically or not. It isn't funny; it's annoying.

[MilesC56]

You need to stop making your OH maps so well. Its making the maps in my TL look bad by comparison!

[oakvale]

You should stop supporting terrible Southern Democrats.

[Proud Lieberal from Northeast]

He's too polite.

[Χahar]

Far too many unfunny memes. In general, all attempts to be funny are total failures thanks to a juvenile and generally defective sense of humor. Other posts are good, but posts that try to be funny are almost always awful. Attempts to make fun of BRTD are especially bad because the inherent lack of humorous ability is combined with an appalling lack of self-awareness and because attempts to make fun of BRTD are usually really stupid in general.

[President Marokai]

Incredibly smart, but doesn't really use that to great effect as much as he should. His tendency to post one-liners or very very short posts when he certainly has the intellectual capacity to post more than that, gives him a worse reputation than he should have.

[pillage the village, trash the scene]

Too much liberal in Senate.

[Proud Lieberal from Northeast]

His posts on what-if board could be little longer.

[Free Palestine]

He can sometimes come across as a bit...unnecessarily mean.

[President Marokai]

A fundamentally good guy, a fact that is eclipsed by his tendency to troll a bit too much.

[Dr. Cynic]

He has a tendency to take things a bit too seriously and I've seen him engage in arguments that could have been avoided. As good a poster as Marokai is, I imagine him sometimes as just being way too wound up.

[Fuzzy]

Cynic should just join the Labor Party already. 

[Dr. Cynic]

Cynic should just join the Labor Party already. 

Actually, I did.

[Fuzzy]

Cynic should just join the Labor Party already. 

Actually, I did.

Crap, sorry.  lol

[Proud Lieberal from Northeast]

Fuzzy: There's absolutely nothing wrong with him... but he should never again talk about quitting Atlas

(Btw, we finally have a criticism thread that isn't turning into a bitchfest).

[Hashemite]

You must finish all your timelines. I know I'm pretty bad at what I preach too, but I promise I'll finish them before I die.

[President Marokai]

The stubborn desire to continue calling himself a centrist absolutely has to stop, because he's just a social democrat that doesn't like labor unions.

He has a tendency to take things a bit too seriously and I've seen him engage in arguments that could have been avoided. As good a poster as Marokai is, I imagine him sometimes as just being way too wound up.

You're unfortunately not far off, though I can't really help it. About a year and ahalf ago I remember having a minor argument with my grandmother, and as I was walking away, my mother pulled me aside, and preparing to be a nurse at the time, decided to check my blood pressure after the argument. She looked at me with genuine concern and said "Herbie, if you were 20 years older, you'd be having a stroke right now. Chill out."

/shrug

[Insula Dei]

Don't get when and how Japanese anime and manga stuff became so weirdly popular in the 'West'. Find it somewhat annoying as well for reasons that are difficult to pinpoint.

[ChairmanSanchez]

Needs to get rid of the creepy sig picture with Newt and the elephant.

[Free Palestine]

I can't think of any criticisms.