Is mewithoutYou the best Christian music of all time?

[So the Heroes Fall]

Easily. Seeing them in June now, can't wait, I'm feeling like a 14-year old girl about to see Justin Bieber.

I am so going to wear the shirt of a band that promotes atheism to be "ironic", just like I changed into an Ampere shirt after I was dunked.

[asexual trans victimologist]

'Adam Lay Ybownden', 'O Salutaris Hostia', and Allegri's Miserere are Christian music, so no.

[So the Heroes Fall]

Allegri's Miserere is Christian music, so no.

*listens*

OK I made it about a minute in. This most certainly does not compare to this or this.

Also I can't understand any of it. It might as well be in the original Latin.

[Senator Napoleon]

You may be on to something.
The Fox, The Crow, And The Cookie is another gem from their discography.

[So the Heroes Fall]

Tweed sent me this a bit ago pointing out based on this the new record should be great. He was right: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jv2k_3bUdrg

I haven't listened to the whole thing yet, but I'll definitely be picking up the vinyl version on Tuesday when it hits.

[Senator Napoleon]

Speaking of vinyl, In a Market Dimly Lit is another favorite.

[Diabolical Minds Think Alike]

I really dig mewithoutYou but I still think The Devil Wears Prada is my favourite Christian band. I've always said that if I ever convert back to Christianity, it'll be because of The Devil Wears Prada.

[So the Heroes Fall]

The Devil Wears Prada are nothing but very generic fifth wave metalcore indistinguishable from dozens of other bands.

[realisticidealist]

lol

[Diabolical Minds Think Alike]

The Devil Wears Prada are nothing but very generic fifth wave metalcore indistinguishable from dozens of other bands.

-___- go away -___-

[© Tweed the Younger]

The Power of Failing was probably better than anything mwY has done.  you may categorically argue that Mineral was not 'Christian music', but neither is mwY a 'Christian band' nor Christian rock.

[So the Heroes Fall]

The Power of Failing was probably better than anything mwY has done.  you may categorically argue that Mineral was not 'Christian music', but neither is mwY a 'Christian band' nor Christian rock.

That album has like only like two Christian songs on it. Most of Mineral's more Christian songs were on EndSerenading. Also mewithoutYou has had far more explicit Christian references in their songs than anything Mineral had done (also think of the meaning of "A->B Life")

[Diabolical Minds Think Alike]

Tweed, the outspoken Atheist and BRTD, the token Christian Leftie, discussing Christian music.

I smell a sitcom!

[So the Heroes Fall]

Lots of atheists like the Christian music I do. It's not like it's the awful stuff on Christian radio or whatever.

[Diabolical Minds Think Alike]

Lots of atheists like the Christian music I do. It's not like it's the awful stuff on Christian radio or whatever.

I like some Christian music. Just not the "JEEEEEEEEEZUUUUUUUUUUUSSSSSSSS ROOOOOOOOOOOOSEEEEEE AND DATS Y HE LOOOOOOVESSES MEEEEEEEEEE" kinda stuff.

[Senator Napoleon]

Lots of atheists like the Christian music I do. It's not like it's the awful stuff on Christian radio or whatever.

exactly.

[asexual trans victimologist]

Also I can't understand any of it. It might as well be in the original Latin.

Oh God

[So the Heroes Fall]

Oh so it is in Latin after all? LOL. Nathan do you have a last.fm? It'd be funny to compare us.

Tweed, if you get an LDS baptism are you going to wear a band shirt and if so which one? I wore a Jawbreaker shirt.

[asexual trans victimologist]

I don't, but a friend's pressuring me to get it, so if I do comparing with you will definitely be interesting/amusing.

[So the Heroes Fall]

So apparently YouTube has some built in thing to help with shaky videos now. Ha, awesome.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xyyy0AURbv

[CathKhan]

"of all time" is so fitting to the personality of the OP. Seriously? "Of all time"? Have you declared yourself judge of all music from the 500's to present? Oh, but you have certain tastes, and your tastes are "right", and we should agree with you then, and your tastes say that "mewithoutYou" is good, and you like it more than other things, so obviously it has to be the best. Right.

[CathKhan]

As for me? I'd say "What Wondrous Love is This?" from that church hymnal is my favorite.

[So the Heroes Fall]

"of all time" is so fitting to the personality of the OP. Seriously? "Of all time"? Have you declared yourself judge of all music from the 500's to present? Oh, but you have certain tastes, and your tastes are "right", and we should agree with you then, and your tastes say that "mewithoutYou" is good, and you like it more than other things, so obviously it has to be the best. Right.

Uh, it's not much different than if you proclaimed The Doors the best band of all time.

As for me? I'd say "What Wondrous Love is This?" from that church hymnal is my favorite.

This is most certainly better than this. I wish I had recorded them playing it, but honestly it would've been just a blur with how much jumping I was doing during that song. That hymn doesn't even make me want to raise my hands, which should be a minimum for any Christian song.

[asexual trans victimologist]

As for me? I'd say "What Wondrous Love is This?" from that church hymnal is my favorite.

This is most certainly better than this. I wish I had recorded them playing it, but honestly it would've been just a blur with how much jumping I was doing during that song. That hymn doesn't even make me want to raise my hands, which should be a minimum for any Christian song.

Go easy on Cathcon, it's not his fault he's unfamiliar with the greatness that is Boris Ord's majestic setting of 'Adam Lay Ybounden'.

[CathKhan]

"of all time" is so fitting to the personality of the OP. Seriously? "Of all time"? Have you declared yourself judge of all music from the 500's to present? Oh, but you have certain tastes, and your tastes are "right", and we should agree with you then, and your tastes say that "mewithoutYou" is good, and you like it more than other things, so obviously it has to be the best. Right.

Uh, it's not much different than if you proclaimed The Doors the best band of all time.

Don't recall saying that, but if I did, the logic I stated in the quoted post is still just as relevant.

As for me? I'd say "What Wondrous Love is This?" from that church hymnal is my favorite.

This is most certainly better than this. I wish I had recorded them playing it, but honestly it would've been just a blur with how much jumping I was doing during that song. That hymn doesn't even make me want to raise my hands, which should be a minimum for any Christian song.

Actually don't seem like that bad of a band, though I can't claim to be a huge fan of the singer.

As for what I mentioned, it should be mentioned that I listen to it with my church's cantor, not that dude that's singin' it.

And lastly, what do you mean by hand-raising? You mean This? In any case, as I always say when our current organist goes into that one song, "We're Catholic, dammit! We don't sway to our music!" and I'll reiterate here as well. I don't listen to music to be physically moved per se (sp?), I prefer to be mentally absorbed. I don't really need to do some weird motion to do such. I don't party in church is what I'm saying. You seem to feel a need to be entertained by what's in church. I don't wanna start a feud here or something, but you seem to be just as intolerant as me on music (more so?) just in the opposite direction.